A few days ago a Realtor from another brokerage company called me to ask my opinion on what his seller needs to disclose on our
Colorado Seller's Property Disclosure form. He was specifically asking about carpet that was under a runner by the back door of the home. Apparently the sun has somewhat faded the carpet in the room but the carpet under the runner was much darker since it has never been exposed to the sun.
So, what do you think? Should the seller disclose the carpet condition to perspective buyers? Or do you think it is not a big deal one way or the other? Some brokers and sellers would think the buyer's home inspector will find the carpet condition and it is therefore not worth mentioning.
Another way of looking at the situation is that the faded carpet condition is not a material item like a flooded basement or a fire in the attic would be so it does not need to be disclosed.
So, what is the right answer? - What do you think?
The answer I gave to the other broker is probably quite different than you or the other broker expected. My answer was that the non faded portion of the carpet below the runner did not need to be disclosed on the Seller's Property Disclosure BECAUSE to most effectively market the home in our very difficult market, the seller actually only has one option. That is to replace the carpet. The home is nearly not capable of selling at all with any defects present. There are just too many homes on the market today for all of them to sell. We probably have ten buyers in any given price range for every twenty listings in that price range. So, buyers today can be very demanding - or should I say selective. Homes that have anything wrong with them just get passes over.
The issue of faded carpet is a property defect just like a dented fender on a car would be to a car dealership. When was the last time you ever saw a damaged car on a car dealer's lot. They know that a damaged car basically has no chance of selling. The damage must be repaired in order for the car to sell. Selling a home in today's very strong "buyers market" is no different.
If the seller did not want to replace the carpet, I personally would then disclose the two tone carpet condition in the Seller's Property Disclosure. I would also be sure the sellers knew that their chances of selling the home without replacing the carpet or at least crediting the buyer money to buy replacement carpet after closing would be very unlikely.
I have been helping buyers and sellers with their housing needs for the past 30 years. I look forward to assisting you. Feel free to call or
email me. -
Bill Kosena, ABR, CRS, SRES -303-796-0957.